Did you know that constantly having terrible sleep can lead to many mental health problems like depression and anxiety? Similarly, if you sleep on the wrong mattress it can cause backache and sometimes headaches. That’s why there are are different types of mattresses designed for various sleepers—because there’s no one-size-fits-all when it comes to sleep.
The most popular mattress types are plush and firm, but what are the differences between the two and why is it important to choose the right one? You'll find answers to this question and more in our complete plush vs firm mattress guide. At the end, you'll be able to make a decision on which mattress is right for your sleeping habits.
Discover the Best Mattress Deals
Whatever your sleep needs be, Price Point has you covered with mattresses in all comfot levels, sizes, and materials.
Shop MattressesWhat’s the Difference? | Plush vs Firm Mattress
Understanding mattress support and comfort is important when choosing the right bed. First, let’s clarify the difference between a supportive mattress compared to a comfortable mattress.
mattress firmness levels
- Mattress support refers to how much you sink into the mattress.
- Mattress comfort is all about how the surface feels.
For instance, most users won’t sink too deep into a firm mattress, yet it still feels comfortable against your body.
In the firm mattress vs plush mattress debate, plush options like memory foam, gel memory foam, and latex are designed for those who prefer cushioning that cradles the body and are ideal for anyone who sleeps in the fetal sleeping position.
On the other hand, firm mattresses, give you stability and even weight distribution. These are the best mattress for back sleeper types who need proper spinal alignment without excessive softness.
Plush vs Firm Mattress for Side Sleepers
So, what kind of mattress does a side sleeper need? Generally, a mattress that is too firm may cause tension in the joints, while one that is too soft can lack the support necessary to keep the spine aligned. With that in mind, here’s what experts say:
One big issue side sleepers deal with is pressure points in the shoulders and hips—especially when sleeping on a surface that doesn’t contour well. These issues arise because the body’s weight is concentrated on a smaller area, unlike the prone sleeping position, where weight is spread more evenly. To avoid discomfort or joint strain, it’s important to compare mattresses that can give both cushioning and support.
Overall, the best mattress for side sleeper types will typically be a plush memory foam, which molds to the body’s curves to reduce pressure and promote spinal alignment. Plush mattresses strike the right balance for targeted relief where side sleepers need it most.However, options aren’t limited to memory foam varieties. Hybrid mattresses with a soft top layer and supportive coils beneath can also be ideal for side sleepers who need extra reinforcement.
Best Mattress for Side Sleepers: Tempur-Pedic® TEMPUR-LuxeBreeze® 13" TEMPUR-Material™ Soft Tight Top Queen Mattress
Shop This Tempur-Pedic Mattress
Sleeping hot can ruin a good night’s rest but this Tempur-Pedic mattress is built to change that. While the brand has a range of mattress comfort levels, this plush model is especially ideal for side sleepers who need soft, pressure-relieving support without overheating. Its 13-inch design features exclusive Tempur material, which adapts to your shape and temperature for personalized comfort. The Ventilated Advanced Relief layer enhances airflow while relieving pressure on hips and shoulders, perfect for those who favor the side-sleeping position. A Pure Cool Plus layer and heat-diffusing technology pull heat away from your body, and the cool-to-the-touch cover helps keep the surface refreshingly comfortable.
⭐Featured Tempur-Pedic LuxeBreeze Review:
“I've had chronic pain since I was 12, and now, at 24, I can HONESTLY say I've never felt this good. With scoliosis and snapping scapula syndrome, I've lived with daily discomfort-but since getting this mattress, I HAVEN'T FELT PAIN. I'm beyond GRATEFUL.”
We Also Love: Sierra Sleep® By Ashley® Chime Elite 2.0 14" Foam Ultra Plush Tight Top Queen Mattress
Shop This Sierra Sleep by Ashley Mattress
A common question buyers ask along with “What type of mattress is best for a side sleeper” is “Will it cost a lot?” Sierra Sleep by Ashley offers an affordable solution with this option that has be what your body’s been craving. Its 14-inch profile layers high-density memory foam, responsive Laytec foam, and a green tea-infused base for a soothing, supportive sleep surface. Transition foam eases pressure on shoulders and hips so it's ideal for maintaining spinal alignment throughout the night. Topped with a micro cool cover that helps regulate temperature, this mattress keeps hot sleepers comfortable and relaxed.
Plush vs Firm Mattress for Back Sleepers
Next up: How does a mattress affect sleep for those who lie on their backs? Commonly, back sleepers sometimes wake up with stiffness or lower back pain, usually caused by poor spinal alignment or inadequate lumbar support. These issues stem from sagging mattresses or surfaces that are too soft to maintain posture under certain weight constraints.
If you sleep on your back support and pressure relief are extremely important. Hybrid mattresses with firm support systems—especially models with wrapped coils and dense foam layers—help distribute weight evenly. For lightweight back sleepers, a mattress softness guide suggests memory foam for contouring without excess sinkage, while sleepers who are bigger in stature have better success with a firm coil or hybrid model.
Best Mattress for Back Sleepers: Stearns & Foster® Reserve Wrapped Coil Firm Euro Pillow Top Queen Mattress
Shop This Stearns & Foster Mattress
Tired of tossing and turning at night? Learning how to sleep better starts with adjusting your sleep schedule and finding the right mattress. Luckily, this firm Euro pillow top from Stearns & Foster delivers support where it matters most. This luxury hybrid mattress is an excellent fit for those who prefer a supine sleep position.
Its Intellicoil HD system provides responsive support, that adapts to different pressure points for full-body alignment. TEMPUR-Indulge memory foam contours the body for added comfort without sacrificing firmness. What's more, a cooling TENCEL cover and AirVent system help regulate body temperature, to promote a restful night’s sleep.
⭐Featured Stearns & Foster Reserve Review:
“I have tried so many mattresses, and finally i found my match! The Reserve Soft Pillow top. It's like sleeping on a cloud! No more pains when I wake up. I actually enjoy sleeping. Thank you S&F!”
We Also Love: Nectar Premier 5.1 Hybrid 13" Medium Firm Tight Top Queen Mattress in a Box
Understanding mattresses can be daunting, but the Nectar Premier 5.1 Hybrid simplifies the choice for back sleepers who want balanced support and comfort. Its medium-firm feel is achieved through therapeutic memory foam that contours to your body, to reduce pressure points, while individually wrapped coils provide responsive support to maintain proper spinal alignment. The cooling quilted poly-blend cover and micro cool technology work together to dissipate heat, to ensure a comfortable temperature throughout the night. Additionally, the mattress's compatibility with adjustable bases has customizable comfort, which makes it a versatile option for those aiming to enhance their sleep quality.
Plush vs Firm Mattress for Stomach Sleepers
Stomach sleepers frequently deal with neck strain and lower back pain, which can result from sleeping on a mattress that’s too soft. These issues arise because a plush surface allows the midsection to sink, which pulls the spine out of its natural position. When asking what is the best mattress for stomach sleepers, the answer is almost always an extra-firm model.
These mattresses have a level surface that keeps the spine aligned and prevents the hips from dipping which is a common cause of discomfort. Any general mattress buying guide will confirm that firmness is non-negotiable for stomach sleepers.
Hybrid designs with firm coils and minimal foam layers excel in support, which makes them ideal for a stomach sleeper. Plush mattresses should be avoided, as they contribute to misalignment. Firm options can reduce pressure points and ensure restful, pain-free sleep.
Best Mattress for Stomach Sleepers: Stearns & Foster® Lux Estate Wrapped Coil Ultra Firm Tight Top Queen Mattress
Shop This Stearns & Foster Firm Mattress
When considering the plush vs firm mattress debate, stomach sleepers find that firmer options provide the necessary support to maintain proper spinal alignment. The Stearns & Foster Lux Estate ultra firm mattress caters precisely to this need. Its IntelliCoil innerspring with PrecisionEdge Support adapts to varying pressures, for personalized support that prevents the midsection from sinking, which is a common issue for stomach sleepers. Complementing this, the TEMPUR-Indulge Memory Foam Comfort Layers contour to the body's shape, for pressure relief without compromising firmness. The sustainably sourced TENCEL cover, enhanced with cooling fibers, gives you a cool-to-the-touch surface for comfortable sleeping throughout the night.
⭐Featured Stearns & Foster Luxe Estate Review:
“Love this mattress, by far the most comfortable mattress we have ever slept on!! Well worth the price!! My husband and I both have back, hip and leg pain and this mattress has made a world of difference in how we sleep now!!”
We Also Love: Stearns & Foster® Estate Wrapped Coil Ultra Firm Tight Top Queen Mattress
Shop This Stearns & Foster Firm Mattress
The Stearns & Foster Estate ultra firm mattress is designed with stomach sleepers in mind, offering a solid foundation that helps prevent the lower back from sinking. Its Intellicoil Innersprings with PrecisionEdge Support adapts to varying pressure points, for targeted support where it's needed most. Its TEMPUR-Indulge Memory Foam Comfort Layer, developed by Tempur-Pedic, contours to the body's shape, providing pressure relief without compromising firmness. The mattress also features a sustainably sourced TENCEL cover that enhances breathability for a cool and comfortable sleep environment.
⭐Featured Stearns & Foster Estate Review:
“Purchased this mattress after experiencing back pain from sleeping on an older mattress. I'm a stomach sleeper so was looking for a firmer mattress, but my wife is a back/side sleeper. She likes a firmer mattress too, but wanted something that still provided comfort with the support. This mattress fits the bill without breaking the bank. Would recommend.”
Only you know the perfect position that gets you snoozing in no time, but at Price Point Furniture, we’re the experts you can count on to take your sleep routine to the next level. With our exclusive Mattress Center, you can try each option out for yourself in one of the area’s largest mattress showrooms, including the biggest selection of Tempur-Pedic mattress in central Tennessee. Visit us today to start enjoying better sleep tonight!
Why Trust Price Point Furniture?
Price Point Furniture has been the leading furniture retailer in Middle Tennessee for over 24 years, serving our local community since 2001. As a locally-owned business, we understand the unique needs and preferences of Tennessee families. Our commitment to offering "Where the Price is the Point!" isn't just a tagline – it's our promise to provide exceptional value on quality furniture for your home.
What sets us apart is our dedication to creating an outstanding customer experience through our three core commitments: Great Prices, Pleasant Shopping Experience, and Exceptional Customer Service. With three convenient retail locations across Middle Tennessee, a state-of-the-art distribution center, and an easy-to-use ecommerce option, we make furniture shopping hassle-free. We're proud to maintain 95% in-stock availability on everything we sell, offering industry-leading same-day pickup or next-day delivery options.
Our showrooms feature an extensive selection of living room furniture, bedroom sets, dining room collections, recliners, home office, and mattresses. We carry trusted brands like Tempur-Pedic, Nectar, Sealy, England, Liberty, Ashley, and more. Our professional, uniformed sales team members are knowledgeable experts ready to guide you through our showrooms, answer your questions, and help with room design to create your perfect space.
With a best price guarantee backed by 24 years of furniture expertise, Price Point Furniture remains dedicated to taking care of our customers at every step of your furniture buying journey.
Shop Mattresses at Price Point Furniture
Looking to settle the debate between plush vs firm mattresses for your home? Visit Price Point Furniture today to explore our extensive collection of quality mattress options at unbeatable prices. Our friendly team is ready to help you find exactly what you're looking for, whether you're shopping in our showrooms or online. With next-day delivery available, you can enjoy your new {primary keyword} sooner than you might think! Contact us today at 615-851-4440 or stop by one of our three Middle Tennessee locations to learn more about our plush vs firm mattress selection.
Learn More: Nectar Luxe Mattress vs Premier: A Side-by-Side Comfort Comparison
- Current Promotions - Check out our latest sales and special offers
- Extreme Values - Browse our discounted furniture and clearance items
- Financing Options - Learn about our flexible payment plans
- Shop by Brand - Explore all our quality furniture brands